Yorkshire Red vs Yorkshire Gold: Which Tea Bags to Choose?
By English Tea Store Brand Teas | Premium Private Label Blends | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Comparisons
Compare Yorkshire Red and Yorkshire Gold on strength, packaging, and price per bag to pick the right Taylors of Harrogate blend for your mug.
Quick answer
Choose Yorkshire Red for an everyday, lower-cost black tea that still takes milk well. Choose Yorkshire Gold when you want a noticeably stronger, maltier cup and don't mind paying more per bag, especially if you serve tea in bulk.
Strength and flavor: what changes in the cup
Both blends draw on teas from India, Africa, and Sri Lanka, but they are built for different drinking styles. Yorkshire Red is described as having a strong aroma, rich color, and satisfying flavor. Yorkshire Gold is described as malty with a rich brown color and is noted as a stronger tea that is often enjoyed with milk and sugar.
In practice, that means Red is the more moderate everyday cup, while Gold gives you more malt and backbone. If you drink tea with a splash of milk, both work, but Gold's extra strength holds up better when you add more milk or sugar.
Packaging and price per bag
The two products come in very different formats. Yorkshire Red Tea Bags - 40 count is a 4.4-ounce (125-gram) box with 40 bags, priced at USD 4.61 against a comparison price of USD 6.99. Yorkshire Gold - String and Tag 200 count is a larger pack of 200 individually sacheted bags with string and tag, priced at USD 42.33 against a comparison price of USD 57.99.
Per bag, Red works out to roughly 12 cents at the catalog price, while Gold is roughly 21 cents. That gap reflects Gold's stronger blend and its individual sachets, which add convenience for catering or office service. If you drink one or two cups a day, the 40-count Red box is a low-commitment way to stock your cupboard; the 200-count Gold pack suits households or workplaces that go through tea quickly.
Loose leaf vs bags in this range
The supplied catalog lists these Yorkshire products as bagged teas only; no loose-leaf versions are included in the product records. That matters if you prefer adjusting leaf quantity or composting fewer wrappers. For most buyers, the bag format is the practical choice, and the string-and-tag sachets on Gold make it easy to remove the bag without fishing with a spoon.
Trade-offs to weigh before you buy
- Everyday cost vs strength: Yorkshire Red costs less per bag (about 12 cents at the catalog price) but is the more moderate blend. Yorkshire Gold costs more per bag (about 21 cents) and delivers a stronger, maltier cup. If you drink several cups daily, compare your monthly bag count before choosing Gold.
- Small box vs bulk pack: Red comes as a 40-count box, which suits one or two drinkers. Gold comes as a 200-count pack, which is better value per bag only if you will finish it while the tea is fresh. Check your cupboard space and how quickly you go through tea before buying the 200-count pack.
- Milk and sugar tolerance: Gold is explicitly described as a stronger tea often enjoyed with milk and sugar. Red is described as satisfying with a strong aroma and rich color but is not positioned as the stronger blend. If you take your tea milky or sweet, start with Gold; if you drink it lightly or black, Red is the lower-risk choice.
Product facts at a glance
- Yorkshire Red Tea Bags - 40 count: 40-count box, 4.4 ounces (125 grams), black tea blend from India, Africa, and Sri Lanka. A smaller box keeps your upfront cost low if you want to try the blend before committing to a larger pack.
Yorkshire Red Tea Bags - 40 count - Taylors of Harrogate Yorkshire Gold - String and Tag 200 count: 200 string-and-tag bags in individual sachets; described as a stronger, malty tea often enjoyed with milk and sugar. The individually wrapped bags are convenient for catering or office tea service, and the stronger blend stands up to milk.
Taylors of Harrogate Yorkshire Gold - String and Tag 200 count
Which Yorkshire tea fits you?
Best for
- Drinkers who want a lower-cost everyday black tea that still takes milk
- Small households or first-time buyers who want a 40-count box to try
Not for
- Anyone who wants the strongest, maltiest cup and is willing to pay more per bag
- Caterers or offices that need individually sacheted bags in bulk
